Nearest Office:

Can a Car Insurance Company Drop You After a Claim?

Car Insurance Company Drop You After a Claim

Navigating the intricacies of insurance policies can be a daunting task, especially when understanding the reasons behind potential cancellations or non-renewals.

From the implications of DUIs and DWIs to the lesser-known SR-22 requirements, this comprehensive guide deepens into the key aspects that influence your auto insurance standing.

Discover what puts your auto insurance policy at risk, how to safeguard it, and the state-specific nuances you should know. Dive in to arm yourself with knowledge and ensure uninterrupted coverage.


  • Late or non-premium payments can lead to insurance policy cancellation, among other components like license or registration issues and serious convictions like DUIs, DWIs, or OUIs.
  • Convictions label drivers as high-risk drivers, resulting in substantial insurance premium increases. Companies may also choose not to renew or drop policies following such convictions.
  • Insurer companies can cancel or choose not to renew insurance policies for reasons ranging from fraud and multiple violations to severe financial conditions of the companies themselves.
  • Ensure timely payments, maintain a clean record, communicate openly with your insurance provider, and regularly review your coverage to avoid potential cancellation or non-renewal scenarios.

Reasons why an Insurance Company Drops You

A few reasons why your auto insurance company has decided to drop you most likely include late or nonpremium payments.

Other reasons an auto insurance company might drop you are not disclosing necessary information in the insurance application, having your license and registration canceled or suspended, filing a fraudulent claim or having a frequent claims history, having a medical condition that prevents you from being a safe driver, and lastly, DUIs, DWIs, or OUI.

DUI, DWI, and OUI Convictions

A DUI means driving under the influence. A DUI is a charge related to operating a vehicle under the influence and being impaired by drugs and alcohol. It’s important to note that even prescription and over-the-counter medications can lead to a DUI charge if the person becomes impaired due to taking them.

A DWI, similarly to a DUI, means while intoxicated, depending on the state. A DWI or DUI charge will depend on the state and their legal blood alcohol concentration (BAC) limit.

An OUI means operating under the influence of intoxicating liquor. OUI is mostly a criminal charge related to impaired or drunk driving.

Suppose you are charged with a DUI or DWI. In that case, you can face serious consequences such as fines, suspension of license and registration, and even jail time depending on different factors like the state you were convicted in, if children were riding in the car, or if you were over or under the BAC limit.

Certificate of Financial Responsibility (SR-22 insurance)

An SR-22 is a certificate of financial responsibility usually mandated by a state’s Department of Motor Vehicles (DMV) for drivers who have found themselves entangled in specific motor vehicle incidents or violations.

It’s essential to understand that the SR-22 isn’t an insurance policy. Instead, it serves as a document that vouches for a driver, attesting that they maintain the state’s minimum required auto insurance coverage.

This certificate is often a requirement for individuals who have faced convictions such as a DUI, have been caught driving without insurance, or have accumulated an excessive number of traffic violation points within a short time frame.

The insurance company, once it has issued the appropriate coverage, files the SR-22 document with the DMV on behalf of the driver. This filing ensures that the state knows the driver’s compliance with the mandated insurance requirements.

Being under an SR-22 obligation often results in the driver being labeled “high-risk.” This categorization can increase insurance premiums, reflecting the perceived risk of insuring the individual.

The duration for which an SR-22 is required can span several years and varies depending on the jurisdiction and the specific nature of the infraction or violation.

How do DUI, DWI, and OUI Convictions Impact Insurance?

DUI (Driving Under the Influence), DWI (Driving While Intoxicated), and OUI (Operating Under the Influence) are serious traffic offenses that can have substantial repercussions on a driver’s insurance.

These convictions indicate high-risk behavior, which insurance companies consider seriously when evaluating coverage and premium costs.

The most immediate impact of a DUI, DWI, or OUI conviction on insurance is a sharp increase in premiums. Once a driver is labeled high-risk due to such convictions, insurers will see them as more likely to be involved in accidents or make claims.

As a result, these drivers often face double or even triple the rates they were paying before, depending on the jurisdiction, the insurance provider, and the specifics of the incident. In some severe cases, the premiums can increase even more.

In addition to soaring premiums, some insurance companies can drop you by not renewing an insurance policy after it expires or, in extreme cases, drop it outright after learning of the conviction. This can leave the driver scrambling to find other insurer companies willing to provide coverage.

Moreover, many states require drivers with such convictions to obtain an SR-22 certificate, a form proving they have the necessary insurance coverage. Not all insurance companies offer SR-22-compliant policies, limiting options for affected drivers.

Beyond the immediate aftermath, these convictions have long-lasting effects on insurance. They typically remain on a driving record for several years, affecting insurance rates long after paying fines or driving courses completed.

Over time, the impact on rates might diminish if the driver maintains a clean record post-conviction. However, the stain of a DUI, DWI, or OUI conviction lingers, a persistent reminder of the importance of safe and sober driving.

Insurance Cancellation vs Non-Renewal of Insurance Coverage

Cancelation from the Insurers

The car insurance company could cancel your policy at any time. They can also decide not to renew your insurance policy at the end of a policy term. However, there is no set number of claims that will result in an insurance cancellation or non-renewal.

Before this can happen, some state laws require the insurance company to notify the policyholder beforehand. For instance, in Florida, the state law requires insurance providers to notify the insured in writing 45 days before canceling the ins policy.

Insurer companies can also drop your policy within the first 60 days without explaining why. However, some states, like New York, have laws that require the insurance company to provide a specific reason in the cancellation notice for canceling a policy within the first 60 days' notice.

Non-renewal from the Insurer

Insurance companies can also choose not to renew your auto insurance policy if they stop or reduce sales of a policy in your area. They can only drop your policy if the insurance company ceases business due to a severe financial situation.

Committing insurance fraud can lead an insurance company to cancel and non-renewal. This type of fraud is also illegal, and fraudsters can face multiple felony charges, restitution, and jail time.

If you have too many traffic or moving violations and at-fault accidents, companies can also choose not to renew your policy and drop you. The same goes if you are convicted of a DUI, DWI, or OUI and your license is suspended or revoked. If your policy is canceled, the companies will refund you part of your premium.

Unique Insurance Laws about Cancellation by State

If you are ever in this position, it is beneficial to know your state’s law on insurance cancellation notices.

  • Alabama: Not disclosing accidents or traffic violations from the last three years can terminate your auto insurance coverage.
  • Arizona: if you are a car insurance agent of the insurance company currently insuring you, your policy can be terminated.
  • California: Lying about how many miles you have driven in the past year could result in your policy being canceled.
  • Delaware: if your car is not inspected or fails the inspection, your coverage can be canceled.
  • Idaho: a ticket for racing can get you dropped from your insurance company.
  • Illinois: if the car is defective, you can be dropped from coverage.
  • Massachusetts: If your insurance company decides to reduce their policies, you can be dropped from coverage.
  • North Carolina: if the insurance company terminates your insurance agent, your policy can be terminated.
  • Texas: If a driver frequently uses your car and has their license suspended or revoked, your insurance company can drop you.
  • Tennessee: if car alterations increase risk, your insurance company can drop you.
  • Virginia: if your legal residence is in another state, the insurer can drop you.
  • Washington D.C: if you transfer ownership of your vehicle to someone who is not a beneficiary, your insurance company can drop you.
  • West Virginia: if your license has been suspended for refusing an intoxication test, your insurance company can drop you.

Can Insurance Companies Cancel your Auto Insurance Policy After a Claim?

An insurance company can cancel your insurance policy after filing a claim. Reasons include frequently filing insurance claims, risk assessment, fraud, and payment history.

Frequently Filing Claims

Filing excessive claims or filing multiple claims in a policy period can cause your insurance company to be inclined to cancel your auto insurance coverage. The reason for this is that the insurance company might view you as a high-risk policyholder.

Multiple claims are caused by filing a claim while another is still unresolved; it doesn’t matter how long it has passed between claims.

If you have multiple mishaps during a period, you cannot avoid filing multiple claims since you can’t combine all the claims into one.

If you file multiple claims simultaneously, your premium can increase, or you choose not to renew your policy at the end of its term. Companies may also choose not to renew your policy for any reason.

Risk Assessment

Insurance companies are all about managing risk and keeping the level of risk as low as possible. When you first apply to an insurance company, they will assess your level of risk at that moment.

After you file a claim, especially a significant one, your level of risk will be reassessed. If the insurer determines that insuring you is a big risk, they might decide to increase your insurance premiums or cancel your policy.


If a claim is for a significant amount of money or involves concerning circumstances for the company, such as reckless or illegal activity or behaviors, they can cancel your policy.

The insurance company can also cancel a policy if a claim has been fraudulently filed. If the claim is suspicious, or there is evidence a claim is fraudulent, or that there was misrepresentation on your part, the company can choose to cancel your policy. Remember that breaching certain policy conditions or stipulations can have the same result.

Payment History

Payment history also matters; if you have a track record of making late payments, your insurance may be inclined to cancel your policy after a claim.

If your policy has been canceled after a claim, seek coverage immediately, especially if it’s a legal requirement, such as car insurance. Lapsing in coverage may also lead to higher premiums and potential legal issues.

You can also appeal an unjust insurance cancellation. Always keep thorough records of all interactions with your insurer and documents related to your claim.

Can an Insurance Company Deny you Insurance Coverage?

The short answer is yes; insurance companies can deny you a policy based on certain components, including the insurance company’s underwriting guidelines.

After assessing your insurance application, the insurance may determine if you represent a high level of risk or not. In auto insurance, this could mean having multiple traffic violations, DIU convictions, or numerous accidents. Insurance companies will always check this information to assess your level of risk correctly.

A history of filing fraudulent claims or being involved in a fraud case can make you appear too risky to insure.

Suppose you have a big lapse in coverage in between policies. In that case, insurance providers may see this as a big red flag and deny you coverage- especially if the reason behind the lapse is nonpayment.

In some cases, regulatory restrictions prevent insurance companies from providing coverage to individuals or certain areas.

If you are deemed a high-risk driver to insure, insurance companies may offer you coverage but with a higher premium. For instance, the reason drivers under the age of 25 have higher premiums than the average driver is that they are riskier to insure than the average driver.

If you are denied coverage, insurance companies must provide you with a reason. Suppose you believe this reason is unjust or based on the wrong information. In that case, you can appeal the decision, seek coverage elsewhere, or go to your state’s insurance regulatory body for guidance.

Consequences of being Dropped from an Insurance Company

Being dropped or non-renewed by an insurance provider is a serious situation that can have far-reaching consequences for the individual. The implications touch on financial, legal, and personal aspects of one’s life, and understanding these can be crucial for navigating the aftermath.

The immediate financial implication is the potential increase in insurance premiums. Once an insurer has decided not to cover you, finding a new provider willing to offer a policy might come at a significantly higher cost.

This is because being dropped often indicates to other insurers that the individual poses a higher risk, either due to multiple claims, late payments, or specific incidents like a DUI. High-risk drivers are typically charged more due to the perceived increased likelihood of future claims.

In extreme cases, standard insurance companies might refuse coverage altogether, pushing the individual to seek coverage from specialized high-risk insurers, which charge substantially higher premiums.

From a legal standpoint, there are potential ramifications, especially if the coverage is auto insurance. Most jurisdictions mandate that drivers maintain a minimum amount of liability coverage.

If there’s a lapse in coverage and the individual continues to drive, they risk fines, license suspension, or even imprisonment. Furthermore, if involved in an accident during this uninsured period, the financial consequences can be devastating.

Without insurance, the individual is personally liable for all damages and medical expenses, which can quickly escalate into insurmountable debt.

The personal consequences extend beyond the financial and legal realms. Being uninsured or underinsured can lead to significant stress and anxiety, especially when driving or managing assets. There’s the constant worry of potential incidents that could lead to out-of-pocket expenses.

Moreover, the very act of being dropped can affect one’s sense of security and stability. Insurance provides a safety net, a buffer against unforeseen events, and without it, individuals may feel exposed and vulnerable. Over time, this strain can impact mental well-being, relationships, and overall quality of life.

How to Avoid Insurance Cancellation or Non-Renewal?

Avoiding insurance cancellation or non-renewal is vital to maintaining uninterrupted coverage and stable premiums. By understanding the triggers that lead insurers to take such actions, policyholders can take proactive steps to ensure they remain in good standing with their providers.

It’s essential to prioritize timely and consistent premium payments. Most insurance companies will provide a grace period for late payments, but consistently paying late or missing multiple payments can flag you as a high-risk client.

Setting up automatic payments, reminders, or direct debits can be effective ways to ensure you never miss a due date.

If you anticipate a financial crunch affecting your ability to pay on time, reaching out to your insurance company in advance can sometimes lead to temporary arrangements or solutions.

Another crucial aspect is maintaining a clean and safe record. For auto insurance, it means obeying traffic rules, avoiding accidents, and refraining from high-risk behaviors like drunk driving. Multiple traffic violations or claims in a short span can make an insurer reconsider the viability of your policy.

Similarly, for homeowners insurance, regular maintenance of the property, addressing potential hazards, and preventing issues like water damage or mold can reduce the likelihood of frequent or significant claims. Engaging in preventative measures showcases responsibility and can deter insurance companies from labeling you as high-risk.

I would also like to point out that communication with your home insurance provider is also essential. Suppose you have plans that can cause significant. In that case, that might affect your coverage – like major home renovations or adding a teen driver to your auto policy – inform your insurer in advance.

This proactive approach can help you adjust your policy accordingly and avoid surprises. Also, if you do file a claim, please provide all the necessary information and documentation as soon as possible.

Being transparent and cooperative can expedite the claims process and foster a more trusting relationship with your insurer.

Regularly read, review, plan, and update your coverage. As life changes, so do insurance needs. An annual review of your policy can help ensure that your coverage aligns with your current situation.

Not only does this help avoid over-insurance or under-insurance, but it also signals to the insurance company that you’re an engaged and informed policyholder.

By demonstrating a proactive approach to risk management, you’re likely to avoid cancellation or non-renewal due to oversight or misunderstanding.

Updated: December 2023

Free Insurance Quote

Receive a car insurance quote in 2 minutes or less!

Auto Insurance

Motorcycle Insurance

Homeowners Insurance

Renters Insurance