Nearest Office:

Does car insurance cover theft and stolen cars?

Does car insurance cover theft and stolen cars

Being a victim of theft can be an awful experience, especially if your car is stolen and you are trying to figure out how to recover your property.

This might be a good time to review your policy and check if your insurance can help you recover your property, cover any damages to the vehicle, or reimburse you for your loss.

Discover how car insurance can financially protect you from theft and what safety measures you can take to protect yourself from theft. 

What Type of Auto Insurance Covers Theft?

When considering auto insurance policies and their protection against theft, car insurance offers a variety of coverage. It’s crucial to understand the different types of coverages available and their specific functions.

The best insurance that offers protection against theft is comprehensive coverage. This coverage is designed to cover incidents deemed as “other than collision.”

If your car is stolen, comprehensive coverage covers the loss up to the actual cash value (ACV) of your car, minus any deductible. Comprehensive auto insurance is an optional coverage that also includes damages to the car from theft, such as broken glass, fires, vandalism, and natural disasters.

While essential components of auto insurance, neither liability nor collision coverage protect against auto theft. Liability coverage focuses on damages to third parties when you’re at fault in an accident, covering their medical expenses for bodily injury and property damage.

Collision coverage, on the other hand, deals with damages to your vehicle resulting from a collision with another car or object, like a telephone pole. I want you to know that these coverages won’t help you if your car gets stolen.

It’s worth noting that if thieves steal personal items from your car, such as electronics, clothing, or tools, your auto insurance typically won’t cover these losses. Instead, homeowners or renters insurance might offer protection for personal property stolen from a vehicle, with the usual deductibles applied.

Additionally, some insurance providers offer add-on coverages or endorsements that can provide expanded protection against theft or offer benefits like rental vehicle coverage if your vehicle is stolen.

To ensure robust protection against the theft of your vehicle, comprehensive coverage is the component you need in your auto insurance policy. 

Those with leased or financed vehicles often find that their lenders mandate this coverage. However, for those with older vehicles, it’s advisable to weigh the costs and benefits of maintaining comprehensive coverage based on the vehicle’s current value.

Does Personal Property Insurance Coverage Cover Stolen Items? 

Personal Property Insurance, commonly found within homeowners, renters, and condo policies, plays a pivotal role in protecting the value of an individual’s belongings. 

Its scope often extends to a surprising range of situations, including theft. Understanding the specifics of this coverage can help policyholders navigate unfortunate events like burglaries or thefts more effectively.

At its heart, Personal Property insurance is designed to cover repairing or replacing personal belongings if they are stolen, damaged, or destroyed due to covered perils.

Theft is usually included in this kind of coverage, whether the items are stolen from one’s home, car, or even while traveling. From electronics and jewelry to furniture and clothing, the span of items covered is comprehensive.

A distinguishing feature of Personal Property insurance is its “off-premises” coverage. This means that even if your belongings are stolen from places outside your primary residence, such as from a hotel room or your car, they might still be covered. 

However, there are often limits to off-premises coverage, typically set at a percentage of the overall personal property coverage amount. For instance, a policy only covers up to 10% of the total personal property limit for items stolen off-premises.

It’s essential to be aware of the deductibles and limits associated with Personal Property insurance. A deductible is the amount the policyholder must pay out-of-pocket before the insurance kicks in. 

Additionally, there might be specific limits set for certain categories of items, especially high-value ones like jewelry, art, or collectibles. If the value of such items exceeds standard policy limits, policyholders may consider purchasing additional endorsements or riders to ensure adequate coverage.

When settling a claim for stolen items, insurers typically use one of two methods: Actual Cash Value (ACV) or Replacement Cost. ACV considers the item’s depreciation, meaning it pays out what it was worth at the time of theft, not its original purchase price. 

Replacement cost compensates the policyholder based on the current cost to replace the item with a new one without factoring in depreciation. Policies offering replacement costs tend to have higher premiums, but they can provide more comprehensive coverage in the event of a loss.

While Personal Property insurance provides essential coverage for stolen items, understanding its downsides is crucial. Policyholders should review their policies regularly, consider the value of their belongings, and ensure they have the right type and amount of coverage to meet their unique needs.

How do Car Theft Claims Work?

While distressing for the vehicle owner, the car theft claim process is structured and ensures a thorough investigation and appropriate compensation based on the insurance policy in place.

When you realize your car has been stolen, you must report the theft to the police. Having an official police report is a crucial step, not only for recovery efforts but also for the insurance claim process. After informing the police, the next step is to contact your insurance provider. 

You’ll be required to provide essential details, including the location and time of the theft, a description of the vehicle, any personal property lost within the vehicle, and details of the last known whereabouts of the car. 

During this phase, you’ll also be required to furnish a list of personal items that might have been inside the car, as these might be covered separately under homeowners or renters insurance.

Once the claim is filed, the insurance company will initiate an investigation. This procedure allows the insurance provider to validate the claim and determine the circumstances of the auto theft. An insurance adjuster will be assigned to your case, and they might ask for additional details, including spare keys, financial records, or recent photos of the car.

They’ll also review the police report and may check for any potential liens on the vehicle. This phase ensures the claim is genuine and not a case of insurance fraud. Many insurance companies have a waiting period (often 30 days) to see if the car might be recovered before proceeding with compensation.

If the vehicle isn’t recovered during the waiting period, or if it’s found but deemed a total loss due to damages, the insurance company will move forward with compensation based on your policy’s terms. 

If you have comprehensive coverage, you’ll be compensated for the actual cash value (ACV) of the car at the time of theft, minus any applicable deductible. The ACV considers the car’s original value minus depreciation. 

Once the claim amount is determined and agreed upon, the insurance company will issue a payout. If there’s a loan or lease on the stolen vehicle, the insurance payout might first go to the lienholder to pay off the outstanding amount, with any remaining funds then coming to the policyholder.

Navigating a car theft claim can be stressful, but understanding the process and maintaining open communication with the insurance adjuster can streamline the experience and ensure a fair settlement.

Does Car Insurance Cover Stolen Car Parts?

Car insurance can provide coverage for stolen car parts. Still, the extent of that coverage largely depends on the specifics of the insurance policy and the type of coverage you’ve chosen.

If you have comprehensive coverage as part of your auto insurance policy, stolen car parts are typically covered. Comprehensive insurance is designed to protect against damages to your vehicle not caused by a collision, including theft, vandalism, natural disasters, and other unforeseen events.

For example, if a thief steals the wheels, radio, battery, or catalytic converter from your parked car, comprehensive coverage typically covers the loss minus any applicable deductible.

Like other insurance claims, stolen car parts coverage is subject to deductibles. If, for example, you have a $500 deductible and stolen parts amount to $2,000 in damages, the insurance will pay $1,500 while you’re responsible for the $500 deductible.

 It’s also important to note that the insurance payout is based on the actual cash value (ACV) of the stolen parts, accounting for depreciation. There might also be limits on certain parts, especially if they’re aftermarket or custom parts that weren’t declared when the policy was established.

While thieves sometimes steal entire vehicles, in many cases, they might target specific high-value or easily resalable parts, like GPS systems, high-end rims, or catalytic converters. These “partial thefts” can be quite common, especially in areas where certain car parts fetch a high price in the black market. Similarly, vandalism, where car parts might be intentionally damaged or removed, is also covered under comprehensive insurance.

It’s always advisable to regularly review your insurance policy to ensure you have comprehensive coverage, especially if you live in an area prone to car thefts or vandalism. 

On a preventive note, using anti-theft devices, parking in well-lit or secured areas, and marking valuable parts with identifiable etchings can deter thieves and help recover stolen items.

While car insurance can cover stolen car parts through comprehensive insurance, policyholders must remain informed about their coverage limits, deductibles, and any specific exclusions. Proactive measures to deter theft can also offer an added layer of protection.

What Happens if my Stolen Car is Recovered? 

Suppose your stolen car is recovered after you’ve reported it to the police and your insurance company. In that case, several potential scenarios can unfold, largely dependent on the vehicle’s condition and the timeline of its recovery.

Once your vehicle is located, the police will typically notify you and your insurance company. Before you can take possession of it, the police might hold the car to process any evidence related to the theft.

If the car is found intact with little damage, you can resume possession and usage once the authorities release it. 

However, if the car has been damaged, you should let your insurance company know. If you have comprehensive coverage, the insurer will typically cover the repairs minus any applicable deductible. 

It’s recommended to have the vehicle thoroughly inspected for any damages, even if they aren’t immediately visible, to ensure safety and performance.

If during the time the car was missing, your insurance company settled the claim and paid you for the vehicle’s estimated value, the situation becomes more complex. In many cases, if the insurance company has compensated you for the total loss of the vehicle, they become the car’s legal owner. 

At this point, you can repurchase the car from the insurance company if you wish to retain it, especially if the damages are minor. Alternatively, the insurance company can take possession of the vehicle, selling it through an auction to recoup some of its payout costs. The specifics can vary based on jurisdiction, the insurance provider, and the details of your policy.

In any scenario, timely communication with law enforcement and your insurance provider is crucial to navigate the complexities and make sure the best possible outcome is taken care of.

Safety Measures to Avoid Having Your Vehicle Stolen

A significant stop against vehicle theft lies in choosing your parking spaces wisely. Whenever possible, park in well-lit areas, close to building entrances, or near security cameras. Thieves are less likely to target vehicles that are easily visible to passersby and surveillance systems.

 Also, please always make sure your vehicle is locked, even if stepping away for just a moment. Physical barriers like steering wheel locks or brake pedal locks can also act as powerful deterrents, making the theft process cumbersome and time-consuming for criminals.

Modern cars have alarm systems, but if yours doesn’t, consider installing an aftermarket alarm for added security. Advanced systems can notify you on your smartphone if your vehicle is tampered with.

GPS tracking devices can also be invaluable, not just for tracking daily routes but for locating a stolen vehicle. Also, please always be aware of the interior of your car. Leaving valuables or electronics in plain sight can attract potential thieves. 

You can store items out of sight, preferably in the trunk or glove compartment, and always keep spare keys inside the vehicle. By combining technological aids with vigilant practices, you significantly reduce the chances of your car becoming an easy target.

Car theft can be an impact event in anyone’s life, but taking the proper precautions and having the right insurance policy may put you more at ease. 

Understanding the different policies that makeup auto insurance is crucial, as they all vary in coverage. For instance, one policy can cover vandalism (like comprehensive coverage), while another can only cover medical expenses and damages to a third party (like liability coverage). 

It’s also essential to understand the claims process and structure and how everyday habits can help you decrease the chances of incidents, such as theft, from happening. 

Updated: December 2023

Free Insurance Quote

Receive a car insurance quote in 2 minutes or less!

Auto Insurance

Motorcycle Insurance

Homeowners Insurance

Renters Insurance